employee from 01.01.1920 to 01.01.2025
St Petersburg, St. Petersburg, Russian Federation
employee
Saint Petersburg, St. Petersburg, Russian Federation
UDC 349.23/24
Introduction. The article examines the actions of auditors from the control and audit departments of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation (hereinafter – the MIA of Russia), aimed at detecting theft of funds committed during payroll settlements within the system of the MIA of Russia. The authors paid particular attention to organisational and administrative, accounting and other documents that serve as the subjects of audits for the specified objective. The actions of auditors for the purpose of identifying embezzlement of funds during payroll settlements within the system of the MIA of Russia are outlined. The relevance of the study stems from the expansion of the geographical scope, the increased damage amounts and changes in the methods of committing embezzlement, as well as the need to improve methodologies for departmental financial control measures aimed at detecting embezzlement of funds. Furthermore, the problem is exacerbated by insufficient funding and staff shortages within the system of the MIA of Russia. Methods. The results presented in this article were obtained by the authors using the following methods: analysis of practical experience of the control and audit units of the MIA of Russia in detecting embezzlement of funds during the settlements with personnel regarding monetary allowances and wages; logical methods of comparing the types and methods of embezzlement with the actions of auditors aimed at detecting them; logical comparison of the types and methods of embezzlement with documents that need to be checked to detect embezzlement. Results. Documents are presented that form the subject of audits and inspections conducted with the aim of detecting embezzlement of funds during settlements with personnel within the system of the MIA of Russia. An algorithm of actions for auditors to detect embezzlement of funds during settlements with personnel within the system of the MIA of Russia is outlined.
audit, inspection, departmental financial control, embezzlement of funds, settlements with personnel, algorithm, methodology
1. Belyayeva, Ekaterina K. 2024. “Nekotoryye aspekty deyatel'nosti pravookhranitel'nykh organov pri proizvodstve po ugolovnym delam ob ekonomicheskikh prestupleniyakh” [“Some aspects of the activities of law enforcement agencies in criminal proceedings on economic crimes”] (In Russ.). Nauchnyy aspekt [Scientific aspect] 10, no. 7:1192–9.
2. Golubyatnikov, Sevir P., and Irina V. Bandorina. 2021. “Priemy issledovaniya dokumental'nyh dannyh v praktike vyyavleniya i dokazyvaniya hishchenij denezhnyh sredstv, sovershaemyh v processe i pod vidom raschetnyh operacij po oplate truda” [“Methods of Researching Documentary Data in the Practice of Identifying and Proving Embezzlement of Funds Committed in the Process and Under the guise of Payment Transactions for Labor”]. In: Sofyin A. A. (ed.) Aktual'nye problemy ispol'zovaniya special'nyh znanij pri vyyavlenii i dokazyvanii ekonomicheskih prestuplenij [Actual Problems of Using Special Knowledge in Identifying and Proving Economic Crimes] (In Russ.). 77–82. Nizhny Novgorod : Marko Polo.
3. Gorbacheva, Alena V., and Elena A. Kalinina. 2025. “Ispol'zovanie materialov revizij po proverke zakonnosti osushchestvleniya vyplat zarabotnoj platy i denezhnogo dovol'stviya sotrudnikam pravoohranitel'nyh organov” [“Use of audit materials to verify the legality of payments of wages and salaries to law enforcement officers”]. In: Krygin S. V. (ed.) Sovremennye informacionno-kommunikacionnye tekhnologii v pravoohranitel'noj deyatel'nosti [Modern information and communication technologies in law enforcement] (In Russ.). 38–46. Nizhnij Novgorod : Nizhegorodskaya akademiya MVD Rossii.
4. Eremin, Sergey G. 2000. “Vyyavlenie hishchenij denezhnyh sredstv pri nachislenii i vydachi zarabotannoj platy” [“Some tactical and psychological features of interrogation of witnesses in criminal cases involving crimes in the field of business activity”]. In: Kriminalisticheskie problemy bor'by s prestupleniyami v sfere ekonomiki [Forensic problems in combating economic crimes] (In Russ.). 35–9. Volgograd : Volgogradskaya akademiya MVD Rossii.
5. Klimovich, Larisa P. 2016. “Preventivnye mery preduprezhdeniya hishchenij, sovershaemyh s ispol'zovaniem podlozhnyh buhgalterskih dokumentov” [“Preventive measures for embezzlement committed with the use of counterfeit accounting documents”]. (In Russ.). Vostochno-Evropejskij nauchnyj zhurnal [East European Scientific Journal] 6, no. 4 (June):102–6.
6. Kurochkina, Ekaterina N. 2020. “Formy i metody kontrolya, primenyaemye pri revizii denezhnogo dovol'stviya sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel'noj sistemy” [“Forms and methods of control used in the audit of the salaries of employees of the penal system”]. In: Nikityuk S. M. (ed.) Ugolovno-ispolnitel'naya sistema na sovremennom etape i perspektivy ee razvitiya [The penal system at the present stage and prospects for its development] (In Russ.). 180–6. Ryazan' : Akademiya prava i upravleniya Federal'noj sluzhby ispolneniya nakazanij.
7. Larichev Vasily D., and Alexander Ya. Kazakov. 2015. “Nekotorye sredstva preduprezhdeniya hishchenij, sovershaemyh rabotnikami predpriyatij” [“Some means of preventing misappropriations committed by factory workers”]. (In Russ.). Nauchnyj portal MVD Rossii [Scientific portal of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia] 6, no. 4 (June):115–22.
8. Loginova, Natalia A. 2024. “Osobennosti vyyavleniya hishchenij nalichnyh denezhnyh sredstv na primere organov vnutrennih del” [“Features of detecting the theft of cash by the example of ministeral affairs bodies”] (In Russ.). Finansovyj biznes [Financial business] 248, no. 2 (February):40–3.
9. Loginova, A. Yu., and Maria A. Kubar. 2023. “Reviziya ispol'zovaniya trudovyh resursov i raschetov po oplate truda” [“Audit of labor resource utilization and payroll calculations”]. In: Yashin A. V., Grachev A. A. (eds.) Pravovye i social'no-ekonomicheskie problemy sovremennoj Rossii: teoriya i praktika [Legal and socio-economic problems of modern Russia: theory and practice] (In Russ.). 200–3. Penza : Penzenskij gosudarstvennyj agrarnyj universitet.
10. Mizikovskij, Efim A., and Elena S. Igonina. 2017. “Sposoby i priemy finansovo-ekonomicheskoj revizii pri vyyavlenii hishchenij byudzhetnyh sredstv” [“Techniques of financial and economic audit for detecting the embezzlement of budget funds”] (In Russ.). Vestnik IPB (Vestnik professional'nyh buhgalterov) [IPAR. Future of the accountancy profession], no. 3 (June):18–23.
11. Pivtsayev, A. A., and Alena V. Gorbacheva, Elena S. Igonina. 2025. “Tipichnye sposoby moshennichestva v sisteme nachisleniya i vyplaty zarabotnoj platy rabotnikam” [“Typical methods of fraud in the system of calculating and paying wages to employees”]. In: Sofyin A. A. (ed.) Aktual'nye problemy ispol'zovaniya special'nyh znanij pri vyyavlenii i dokazyvanii ekonomicheskih prestuplenij [Current issues of using specialized knowledge in identifying and proving economic crimes] (In Russ.). 261–5. Nizhnij Novgorod : Stimul-ST.
12. Repnikova, Yulia V. 2016. “Proverka i issledovanie operacij po raschetnomu schetu dlya vyyavleniya priznakov hishchenij denezhnyh sredstv” [“Fulfillment of a monetary obligation when making payments using a payment card”]. In: Gorkina E. V., Kairgaliev D. V. (eds.) Problemy sovershenstvovaniya deyatel'nosti po preduprezhdeniyu i rassledovaniyu prestuplenij [Problems of improving activities on crime prevention and investigation] (In Russ.). 136–9. Moscow : Pero.
13. Solovieva, Evgenia N., and Elena V. Pecheritsa. 2019. “Sposoby ekspertnyh vyyavlenij hishchenij pri vyplate zarabotnoj platy” [“Methods of expert determination of salary theft”]. In: Aktual'nye teoreticheskie i prikladnye voprosy upravleniya social'no-ekonomicheskimi sistemami [Actual theoretical and applied issues of the socio-economic systems management] (In Russ.). 255–8. Moscow : Institut razvitiya dopolnitel'nogo professional'nogo obrazovaniya.
14. Drobac, Jennifer Ann. 2022. “The Misappropriation, Embezzlement, Theft, and Waste of Corporate Human and Financial Assets: Sexual Harassment Reconceived.” ABA Journal of Labor & Employment Law 36, no. 3 (September):425–78. URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/27391498.
15. Fremont-Smith, Marion R. [et al.]. 2004. Pillaging of charitable assets: Embezzlement and fraud // Exempt Organization Tax Review (special report) 46, no. 3:333–346.
16. Kristanto, Kiki [et al.]. 2025. “Embezzlement in the Private Sector: Legal Challenges and Regulatory Gaps in Corporate Governance.” Indonesian Journal of Criminal Law Studies 10, no. 2 (November):801–50.
